Venture Financing - Reality Versus Rumor with Dick Brown
These are not
the Biblical
angels that the
Christians
inherited from
Jewish lore …
nor are they
necessarily
creatures of
good, spirits of
love, or
messengers from
“above” -
blissfully
flitting “on
gossamer wings”.
Historically,
they’re more
closely related
to the “angels”
widely known as
the financiers
behind Broadway
productions and
Hollywood
movies.
Universally,
they’re not in
it for religion
or bright
lights, but
bucks.
Investor angels
provide a large
percentage of
the seed/growth
capital to
companies in the
US. They
typically invest
their own funds,
unlike venture
capitalists who
use OPM (Other
Peoples’ Money).
Although an
individual makes
the final
investment
decision, the
actual funding
may be from
their trust,
business,
limited
liability
company,
investment fund,
etc.
Angel capital
conveniently
fills the gap in
start-up
financing
between
"friends, family
and fools" and
the VC’s. It is
unusually
difficult to
raise more than
a few thousand
dollars from the
3F’s and even
small venture
capital firms
will not
consider
investments
under $1M to
$2M. Thus, as
the biblical
ones, financial
angels bridge a
gap … not
between heaven
and earth, but
between two of
the most common
sources of
capital
available to
most
entrepreneurs.
Angel investment
is a common
second round of
financing for
high-growth
start-ups, and
accounts in
total for almost
as much money
invested
annually as all
venture capital
funds combined,
but into more
than ten times
as many
companies ($26
billion vs.
$30.69 billion
in the US in
2007, and into
57,000 companies
vs. the VC’s
3,918
companies).1
Of the US
companies that
received angel
funding in 2007,
the average
capital raised
was about
$450,000.
However, there
is no “set
amount” for
angel investors,
and the range
can go anywhere
from a few
thousand to a
few million
dollars.
Software
accounted for
the largest
share of angel
investments,
with 27 percent
of total angel
investments in
2007, followed
by healthcare
services, and
medical devices
and equipment
(19 percent) and
biotech (12
percent). The
remaining
investments were
approximately
equally weighted
across high-tech
sectors. Angel
financing, while
more readily
available than
venture
financing, is
still extremely
difficult to
raise.1
Investment
Criteria
Angel
investments bear
high risk and
can be subject
to dilution from
future
investment
rounds. Angels
use about the
same ROI
formulas as VC’s
and seek
investments that
have the
potential to
return at least
10 or more times
their original
investment
within 5 years -
as well as those
that can execute
a defined exit
strategy.
Their Community
According to the
Center for
Venture
Research, there
were 258,000
active angel
investors in the
U.S. in 2007.
According to the
US Small
Business
Administration,
the number of
individuals in
the US who made
an angel
investment
between 2001 and
2003 is between
300,000 and
600,000.
Gradually,
angels started
to coalesce into
informal groups
with the goal of
sharing deal
flow and due
diligence work,
and pooling
their funds to
make larger
investments. One
of the first
(and the best
known) of these
was Hans
Severins’
formation of the
Band of Angels
in 1994 in San
Francisco,
http://www.bandangels.com/.
Perhaps typical
of angel groups,
the Band of
Angel’s track
record is noted
on their web
page: “The Band
has invested
more than $186M
into 200+
companies since
1994. Of these
45 have been
acquired for a
gain, and 9 have
gone public on
the NASDAQ. The
cumulative IRR
for all band
investments
since inception,
including the
losses suffered
through the
bust, is a
positive 18%”.
Such angel
groups are
generally made
up of 10 to 150
accredited
investors
interested in
early-stage
investing. The
more advanced of
these groups can
have full time,
professional
staffs;
associated
investment
funds;
sophisticated
web-based
platforms for
processing
funding
applications;
and substantial
operating
budgets. Some
such as the
NY Angels,
(http://angelsoft.net/angel-group/new-york-angels);
founded by
financial
legend, David
Rose; hand out
more paperwork
and forms to the
new entrepreneur
than comparable
VC’s … and, have
far longer
waiting periods
before being
formally
considered.
Today, there are
dozens of angel
groups,
scattered across
the US and other
advanced
countries, with
varied charters
and called a
variety of
different names.
Even with the
current
recession, angel
groups have
grown like the
Google’s cash
flow. There’s
hardly a city or
university that
doesn’t have an
angel group.
Just check on
the Internet.
General Angel
Characteristics:
-
They are business executives and owners.
-
The average age of an angel investor is 47.
-
Few are younger than 35 or older than 65.
Most are white males and 72% have a college degree. -
The average income is greater than $90,000.
-
The average net worth is $750,000.
-
Their average investment is $25,000 to $50,000 per deal.
-
Their acceptance of deals is around 20%. (They actually invest in 1 out of every 5 deals that they see.)
-
Only 1 in 12 is a lone investor. (For those weak in arithmetic, this means that 11 out of every 12 angels need someone else to invest in the deal with them.)
Types of Angels
Entrepreneur/Executives
These angels
exist within the
power structure
of your industry
or their own.
They are most
grateful for
their success
and often
somewhat
embarrassed by
it. They are
very willing to
help newcomers
to the game.
Often they will
devote almost
excessive time,
money and effort
to help you
succeed. They
remember that
early in their
careers, someone
once helped
them. They
rarely have
“hidden agendas”
and are close to
your “perfect
investor”.
Wealthy
Individuals
There are many
wealthy
individuals who
enjoy helping
new businesses.
The best
candidates may
also have an
interest in the
specific kind of
business you are
starting.
Generally, they
do not have
formal
investment
evaluation
criteria. They
rely instead on
instinct and on
endorsement
introductions
from other
successful
individuals or
advisors.
Most expect a
handsome ROI
over a
relatively short
period of time.
Rarely do they
intend to become
permanent
investors in the
business.
Wealthy
individuals
actively monitor
their
investments, and
most frequently
as board
members.
They enjoy the
social prestige
of being
benefactors to
successful new
businesses.
Their personal
contacts and
business
abilities are
valuable
resources.
“Corporate”
Angels
There are many
companies that
are looking for
new products and
services to
broaden their
business
markets.
Depending on
your venture,
they may invest
money, time,
facilities,
technical
support and many
other
potentially
valuable assets.
They can move
quickly …
sometimes too
quickly from the
view of their
own investors.
Biggest barrier? Political factions in their company playing “not invented here!”
Best advantage? Have the CEO like you.
What are the
differences
between the
Executive/Entrepreneur
and the
Corporate Angel?
The former
invests their
personal money.
The latter uses
company money.
The
Entrepreneur/Executives
and the
Corporate Angels
should be at the
top of your list
as sources of
capital. In
addition to
money they have
power, influence
and many
friends.
Even better, you
can find them
fairly easily.
Every state has
publications
that list all
the companies in
the state, by
region, by
industry, by
size, and other
categories with
the names of the
executives and
the phone/ fax
numbers. Many of
these
publications
sell the lists
and in many
cases on disks,
already
formatted for
“lead tracking
software”, such
as Outlook or
ACT.
Foreign Angels
If you can
locate them,
Non-US Citizens
are perhaps the
very best “pure”
investors. They
have no
protection under
most US
securities laws.
They live in
another country.
They rarely call
you and usually
don’t even
bother showing
up at the yearly
stockholders
meeting. The
real ones are
rich, usually
naive, and
simply trying to
make money.
On the other
hand, they are
terribly hard to
find and close,
even over the
Internet. And,
you don’t know
who they truly
are … or, the
real reason they
want to invest
in your company.
And if they are
“Bad Angels” or
“Fallen Angels”,
they are smart
enough not to
have their
business cards
read “Tijuana
Drug Cartel,
Mexico.”
Having opened
this subject,
the single
largest problem
for organized
crime is what to
do with all the
cash. It is not
uncommon for
criminal
organizations to
form “front
companies” that
invest in
interesting
opportunities.
They’re very
good at hiding
the real
ownership.
Legend has it
that the Mafia
started and
owned the NY
banks that
gradually
morphed into
American
Express. Be
careful whose
money you take!
1
Source:
Wikipedia
- More about
Angels Next
Month -
- 30 -
